CathBlog - Old Catholic anti-semitic attitudes die hard


Mary, the mother of Jesus, was Jewish. Her religious worldview was shaped by the covenant of Sinai, the narratives of the Hebrew scriptures, the rituals and festivals of Judaism, and ethical observance of Torah. 

She would have participated in synagogue worship, celebrated Jesus’ circumcision, kept the Sabbath, observed Jewish dietary laws, as well as purity laws relating to menstruation and childbirth.

This picture is filled out by Elizabeth Johnson in Truly Our Sister: A Theology of Mary in the Communion of Saints (NY: Continuum, 2003). While acknowledging the shortage of specific facts about Mary’s life, Johnson explores the social, political and religious world of first century Palestine in which the mother of Jesus lived. 

Her work in this area remains an important landmark, because to this day, despite the church’s newfound embrace of its Jewish roots and the Jewishness of Jesus, the Jewish identity of Mary attracts relatively little attention.

Paradoxically, the universal appeal of Marian symbolism - in itself praiseworthy and resulting in so many beautiful works of art and expressions of piety - can have the effect of hiding the real person at the heart of the symbol, hence concealing the centrality of Judaism to the Christian story.

On a darker note, the anti-semitism that has infected so much of Christian history, and which has only in recent decades been decisively confronted by official church teaching, has tainted Marian interpretation as well. 

The church’s gradual separation from its Jewish roots was accompanied by a hardening of anti-Jewish attitudes. As Edward Kessler of the Woolf Institute at Cambridge has pointed out, when Jewish polemic of the early Middle Ages challenged the teaching of the virgin birth, it reinforced the Christian view of Jews as particular enemies of Mary.

These days we live in a brighter era in terms of Jewish-Christian reconciliation. Today the church positively embraces its Jewish heritage, affirms the enduring validity of the Jewish covenant, and encourages the unique relationship between Christianity and Judaism. It teaches that the Jews are not to be held collectively responsible for the death of Jesus, and that anti-semitism is the antithesis of the gospel. 

We can rejoice in the bold leadership taken by the council fathers at Vatican II in re-setting the church’s compass in relation to the Jewish people. But old attitudes die hard. 

Even today it is necessary to counter the residue of anti-Judaism in grassroots Christian consciousness. I see this first hand in some parish circles where the charge ‘but the Jews killed Jesus’ still holds sway, and the odd racial slur slips out as a ‘joke.’  

It can be seen in some instances of mainstream gospel commentary where the ‘loving and liberating’ Jesus is simplistically cast as opposing his Jewish religion which is stereotypically portrayed as ‘rigid and legalistic.’ I have seen it in my own writing of years gone by, when my zeal for the gospel had not yet deeply assimilated the Council’s teaching in Nostra Aetate 4.

It will take time for Catholics to fully embrace this new awareness of Judaism as being ‘intrinsic’ to their faith tradition, just as it will take time to win the trust of the Jewish people after centuries of damage done through anti-Jewish ‘displacement’ theologies.

But embrace it we must, and, given the power that the person and symbol of Mary wields in the Catholic psyche, a significant step forward we can all take as Catholics is to reacquaint ourselves with Miriam of Nazareth, faithful daughter of Israel, the Jewish woman whom we lovingly esteem as ‘Mary.’

Teresa PirolaTeresa Pirola is a Sydney-based freelance faith-educator and founder/coordinator of the Light of Torah ministry.

Disclaimer: CathBlog is an extension of CathNews story feedback. It is intended to promote discussion and debate among the subscribers to CathNews and the readers of the website. The opinions expressed in CathBlog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the members of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference or of Church Resources.

Mass on Demand


From Parish of Our Lady of The Way, North Sydney & Lavender Bay. The first Mass of the day on YouTube

Mass Online


Live streamed from Our Lady of the Rosary Cathedral, Waitara


Daily Prayer

Daily Prayer

All your daily readings, reflections and prayers can be found here...