Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

SSPX Bishop Williamson apologises for "imprudence"

Published: February 02, 2009

SSPX Bishop Richard Williamson has apologised to Pope Benedict for the "unnecessary distress and problems" caused by his "imprudent remarks" but the fallout over the lifting of his excommunication continues.

The Washington Post reports that Bishop Williamson posted the statement on his personal blog.

Williamson's apology came in the form of a letter, dated January 28, to Cardinal Dario Castrillón Hoyos, head of the Vatican office that deals with the Society of St Pius X.

"Amidst this tremendous media storm stirred up by imprudent remarks of mine on Swedish television, I beg of you to accept . . . my sincere regrets for having caused to yourself and to the Holy Father so much unnecessary distress and problems," Williamson wrote.

The bishop also expressed gratitude for Benedict's cancellation of his excommunication and promised to "offer a Mass" for the pope and Castrillón.

In an introductory comment for readers of his blog, Williamson suggested that critics had exploited his remarks merely to attack Benedict.

"Last week's media uproar" was "surely aimed rather at the Holy Father than at a relatively insignificant bishop," he wrote.

Williamson also hinted that his apology was not a retraction of his inflammatory historical statements but a gesture of deference to the pope.

Introducing the letter to Castrillón, Williamson noted that the late Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, founder of the Society of St Pius X, "gave his Society the example of never so cleaving to God's Truth as to abandon respect for the men holding God's Authority."

On Friday, an Israeli government official said the Jewish state maintains good relations with the Vatican despite the controversy over Williamson, the Associated Press reported.

Israel's ambassador to the Holy See, Mordechay Lewy, said "the climate is good" and that there is "a lot of potential for cooperation" between the Vatican and Israel.

However on Saturday, Israel's Minister for Religious Affairs, Yitzhak Cohen, threatened to suspend relationships with the Vatican following the pope's pardoning of Williamson, German news magazine Spiegel reported.

Cohen said he recommended "completely cutting off connections to a body in which Holocaust deniers and anti-Semites are members."

Meanwhile, the Catholic leadership in Regensburg has banned Bishop Williamson from entering its churches.

Gerhard Ludwig Mueller, the Catholic bishop of the German city of Regensburg, said that Williamson would not be allowed to set foot in his cathedral or on any other church property.

Public prosecutors have opened an inquiry against Williamson over his denial of the Holocaust during an interview recorded with Swedish television last week at Zaitzkofen. Holocaust denial is a crime in Germany.

The German Conference of Catholic Bishops has also rejected Williamson's remarks.

SOURCE

Bishop Apologizes to Pope but Does Not Retract Holocaust Denial (Washington Post)

Regensburg Bans Holocaust-Denying Bishop From its Churches (DW World)

Pope criticised over Holocaust denier (The Age)

Israel threatens to suspend Vatican ties (Press TV)

 

 

Response to articles is welcome though it may take up to 24 hours for the posting to appear. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories & issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked.
If you have any problems please email news@cathnews.com
Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Recent Comments

  1. Just another 'Nutter" for the Vatican to worry about. There are a few of these deniers of the Holocaust lurking about. There is no cure for ignorance, stupidity, and a refusal to believe the facts! I hope our Jewish brothers & sisters realise this is just ONE ignoramus, and does not reflect the attitude of St. Pius X Society.

  2. One of the biggest reasons to be ex-communicated and also Williamson should leave the Church.He has no right to be a member of the Catholic church or even call himself a Christian.I do not understand why this man is still a bisshop. The Christian religion has no need for people like this. What are we??? Man or mouse??? If we are truly man then we of course will ban a man like Williamson.Only racist people say things like he did and so he is a racist. These are the exact words of a right extremist the way he has put it and right extremists cannot be members of the Christian Church.

  3. Williamson should be fired. When he is not fired ASAP, then I see the Catholic Church as a promotor of Anti-Semitism and the denial of the HOLOCAUST. When he is not being fired then the Pope is saying the same thing as Williamson.

  4. It isn't just Bishop Williamson. There are many SSPX'ers whose families were supporters of the pro Nazi Vichy French regime during WWII. Many of these had conspiratorial views about the Jews.

  5. The Bishop's remark was not 'imprudent' - it was plain 100% false. But it sounds like he is rationality-challenged and as Stanley J. Harris says, he is just one of a minority of nutters. Every religious groups has its nutters, and one should just tell them they are wrong and ignore them. It's good that the Pope gagged him.

  6. "Israel's Minister for Religious Affairs, Yitzhak Cohen, ... said he recommended "completely cutting off connections to a body in which Holocaust deniers and anti-Semites are members."
    That would mean cutting off connections to every religious, political and other organisation and nation in the world. Including Judaism and the Israeli Republic, which include some Holocaust deniers and anti-Semites as members and citizens.

  7. The Church's exclusionary tactics of late have caused me to question my faith.. Benedict's messages of love and tolerance gave me hope when I first had doubts about his history upon election..

    But his ultra conservative modus operandi and this continued and active intolerence of the most marginalised and hurt within our society only make me want to leave the safety of a faith which has given me so much in the past but where I continue to feel more and more irrelevant..

    To look away and continue the indulgence in such intolerance is to agree to it... I may need to go to Mass and speak to my priest about it.. but the more that happens the less likely it will be that, like many others, I will return.




  8. So Williamson "apologises" for "causing the Holy Father so much uneccessary distress"? But does he recant his monstrous views on the Holocaust? Does he apologise to the Jewish people for his sinful utterances? Of course not; he is a dangerous and delusional stooge. Bravo to the Bishop of Regensburg for excluding him. Let's see which other ordinaries have the same courage.

  9. yes you're so right Mark Vincent. We must kick out of the Church all the racists and all the "right extremists" (and the Left extremists??). And all the others who have ever said or done anything extreme or uncharitable or sinful. I'm afraid you'll have to kick me out too. Then you'll be the only one left in the Church and you'll be happy.

    Michael: I hope your country is never invaded and conquered within weeks by a brutal extremist murderous atheist miltary machine, and you are then forced to choose between suffering direct military rule by the conqueror, a seemingly hopeless and deadly guerrilla warfare (with your wife and children?) or supporting a "puppet" regime, at least allowing yourt own countrymen some say in governing the country, and dilute and prevent the worst excesses of the conqueror. Some Frenchmen chose to support the Vichy regime. Others like Abp Lefebvre's father joined the resistance, were captured and died in a Nazi concentration camp.

    dtroy, you seem a bit confused. Apparently you think the pope shows "exclusionary tactics" by LIFTING the excommunications, but he would show "love and tolerance" by continuing to excommunicate the SSPX bishops!

    "indulgence in such intolerance"? (I presume you mean Bp Williamsons Holocaust minimising.) Could the Pope and the Church (and even, it must be admitted, the SSPX) possibly have been any more crystal clear that they totally and utterly condemn it?

    What on earth do you mean by what you call B16's "continued and active intolerence of the most marginalised and hurt within our society"?? Or are you trying to be ironical?

  10. The SSPX apologias are really delusional to this day. They never accept the fact that their founder signed off on the Vatican II documents; then later did a huge dummy spit.
    The SSPX leaders are not very bright. Their best hope is to agree to the Vatican II document because they contain a lot of motherhood statements and are not delivering new doctrine. The SSPX should just stick to the Tridentine Latin Mass and interpret Vatican II in light of Tradition without the funny business of presenting it as a contradiction to the Faith of Ages. Then they will gain more supporters.
    But all this ongoing rationalising of hostility with French passive aggressive behaviours will continue to turn people off them. I would support them if they dropped their pointless hostilities masked by a theology that doesn't grow.

  11. A big deal about nothing,

    The hard truth is that these four men were unfairly ex-communicated and should rightfully be let back in the Church.

    The concerns of the SSPX are not the rants of nutters, but simply genuine concerns that millions of millions of Catholics across the globe would share and for good reason.

    We as Catholics have to all look at ourselves and ask why the Second Vatican Council has borne such rotten fruits and what can be done to reform the great number of errors that have swept into the modern Church.

    The hard truth is that SSPX would make faithful servants of the Church and the Vatican and the Church in general should rather consider whether their is any use having clear dissenters and people that do not deserve to call themselves Catholic.

  12. If people really feel strongly about opposing Williamson, perhaps they can contact their pastor or bishop about it. Or if everyone outraged would withhold their donation to the Church for a Sunday or two, then that might get the Vatican's attention. They can send their money elsewhere.

  13. As far as I am aware, Williamson has never denied the "shoah" happened, only that the actual figures may be incorrect. Is this so terrible?

    Is 6,000,000 an article of faith?

    The mass hysteria surrounding this whole issue is absurd.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. Legionaries of Christ founder led double life

    A Legionaries of Christ spokesperson has revealed the order has concluded that its founder, Mexican priest, Fr Marcial Maciel Degollado, was guilty of conduct that is "difficult to understand, and inappropriate for a Catholic priest."

  2. Controversial Austrian priest now a bishop

    The new bishop of Linz, Austria, is controversial priest, Fr Gerhard Maria Wagner, who suggested Hurricane Katrina was provoked by sin in New Orleans and described Harry Potter novels as "satanism", Pope Benedict has decided.

  3. French priest exposes "Holocaust by bullets"

    French priest, Fr Patrick Desbois, have opened an exhibition in Paris exposing the "Holocaust by bullets" perpetrated by Nazi forces on Jews in the Ukraine.

  4. UK nurse suspended over prayer offer

    British community nurse, Caroline Petrie, has been suspended without pay and faces sacking and possibly being struck off after she offered to say a prayer for an elderly patient.

  5. All black on the way out for NZ priests

    Palmerston North Bishop Peter Cullinane has launched a nationwide search in New Zealand for a new symbol to identify Catholic clergy.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.