CathNews - a Service of Church Resources

Have Your Say 

Recent Comments

1. Against all the traditional interpretation of the ages, (e.g. that of Cardinal Martini, and Raphael and Henri Nouen) I do not see this parable as one of a trilogy of Chapter 15 of Luke, making us believe that God is the forgiving father (as the other two do)! Sadly, in my opinion, it has been wrongly and badly interpreted. There is no concluding verse here, as in the other two parables, that there was "rejoicing in heaven" - in fact I think it is about a very problematic and dysfunctional family situation here on earth. That family needs to get its act together! They need to try dialogue, a bit of common prayer ( perhaps a visit to the synagogue) and also one to their dear long dead mother's grave. Then perhaps there might be time for the party! Just ask yourself, which child is the father most like: the party pooper or the hard worker? I am sorry if this interpretation bothers "pious" ears - but it doesn't for one minute, destroy the nature (forgiving and just) of God. Cheers,
   Vince

   Posted By: Vince Carroll MSC

2. Well you certainly get an A for originality Vince. I wonder what the Apostles would have thought of your idea that Christ's Prodigal Son parable was about the need for family dialogue and prayer. I'm sure your interpretation won't "bother" anyone but it will probably amuse many. And St Luke does not say that the mother was dead.

   Posted By: Ronk

• » Advertise in CathNews

Email to Friend Please fill out the following details (fields marked with a * are mandatory):
Send To Email Address*:
Send To Name *:
Sent By Email Address*:
Sent By Name *:
Text to include in email:
Captcha validation:	please enter the code above:

^ Page Top

Comment on this article

More from this section

1. Feature - Obama's stem cell lifeline

   The recent decision to lift the ban on Federal funding of embryonic stem cell research in the US will have far reaching consequences both for the US and the global research effort in this area. The original decision by the Bush government led to waste and absurdity. - Peter Gunning, abc.net.au

2. Feature - Towering over a grey Oxford sky

   My first glimpse of Cardinal Pell is rather surreal. His unmistakable, craggily handsome head emerges about 20 feet above me, framed by a grey Oxford sky. He is leaning out of the window of his rooms at Merton College and is preparing to throw down the key to let us in. - Luke Coppen, The Catholic Herald

3. Feature - Calming presence for others

   I have read that a sign of us being apostles of Christ is the calmness and peace with which we face life and its challenges. Calmness is not a concept or experience that receives a lot of airplay these days. We hear a lot about the need for confidence, assertion, resilience and strength, but to be calm in the face of adversity or crisis, gives much solace and security to those around us. - Pauline Connelly, The Southern Cross

4. Feature - No winner for Tabcorp

   Tabcorp invokes the secularist mantra of people have a choice as to what they do on the day and how they wish to spend it. Quite right. And the choice of so many is to spend Good Friday as a day quite different from any other day. - Bishop Christopher Prowse, Herald Sun

    

5. Feature - Ireland's need for a Lenten change

   The mood in Ireland in these days seems to be less that of Lenten sackcloth and ashes and more that of discontented and often righteous indignation. At first, people seemed almost in denial about the prospect of recession, then bewildered by the pace of the downturn. Now however, as the reality bites, one can sense a growing public and private discontent, anger, anxiety, even fear and desperation. - Fr Gerry O'Hanlon, Thinking Faith