Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

A sense of secrecy in Calvary deal: Coleridge

Published: November 02, 2009

Archbishop of Canberra and Goulburn Mark Coleridge said the deal surrounding Calvary Hospital's purchase by the ACT Government has been shrouded in secrecy and a false sense of inevitability, the Canberra Times reports.

"I also shared that sense of things going on behind closed doors, secret deals being done and also the sense of inevitability that was being generated, or the illusion of inevitability that there was no point of putting up any resistance or asking questions," he said, referring to criticism last week by Sydney's Cardinal George Pell over the deal.

ACT Health Minister Katy Gallagher accused the clergymen of putting pressure on the sisters of the Little Company of Mary to halt the sale.

"The archbishop and the cardinal have chosen their time to come out and lobby and I think, from where I sit, that is to place maximum pressure on the nuns as they contemplate this," Ms Gallagher said.

The proposed sale of Clare Holland House to Little Company of Mary Health Care (LCMHC), as part of the wider deal, is also drawing criticism from the ACT Palliative Care Society and nurses working at the hospice, ABC reports.

Around 150 members of the Palliative Care Society (PCS) held a meeting earlier this week to discuss the issue.

The group withdrew an invitation to Health Minister Katy Gallagher and LCMHC but Liberals health spokesman Jeremy Hanson was allowed to attend, the report added.

FULL STORY

Church attacks Calvary 'secrecy' (The Canberra Times)

Gallagher's hospice headache (ABC)

ARCHIVE

Calvary sale is anti-Christian: Pell

Make submissions on Calvary sale: Coleridge

Opinion - Knights attempt Calvary rescue

Calvary hospital to be sold to ACT government

PHOTO CREDIT

Image from Calvary Health Care ACT

 

Response to articles is welcome though it may take up to 24 hours for the posting to appear. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories & issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked.
If you have any problems please email news@cathnews.com
Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Recent Comments

  1. ACT Govt Minister Katy Gallagher is playing politics in trying to level criticism at Archbishop Coleridge and Cardinal Pell.
    By making them the focus of her 'consultation' on the proposed purchase by the ACT Govt of Calvary, Ms Gallagher doesn't have to debate the very real critique of the finacial underpinnings of the proposal.
    The proposal, as it stands, of the ACT Government will be bad for the people of Canberra as well as for those of us in the surrounding NSW country areas which have access to Calvary.
    The bottom line is that the ACT Govt's continuing funding of Calvary, run by the LCMHC will actually benefit the ACT Govt finances over the same period that the ACT GOvt say they need to expend $200 million and cannot do this if it remains in Catholic hands.
    And no wonder the the ACT Palliative Care nurses and supporters are up in arms about the proposed sale of the ACT Hospice, Clare Holland House. At the present time, there are nineteen beds in the Hopsice but the ACT Govt will only allow the operation of ten of them. The situation if the the Govt sells the Hospice to the LCMHC would not improve as the Govt could then blame the LCMHC for the shortfall in bed space - approx 400 people are desparately waiting for Hospice care in the ACT.
    The LCMHC and the Archdiocese need to petition the Commonwealth Government for a takeover of ACT Health, it's the only solution for justice for all Canberrans - patients, nurses, doctors and those resident of NSW who need the care in Canberra.

  2. The Archbishop is spot on about secrecy. We now know the ACT government has been pushing for this for over four years, but we the voters didn't hear a word about it until - very conveniently - just after the October 2008 elections. The government's reluctance to put the matter to the electorate is telling - they know it would cost them votes.
    And it's no secret that the radfem mafia in Canberra, which calls the shots in ACT social policy, has been gunning for Calvary for years. See, for example, Angela Shanahan's articel on Amy Haddad,
    (For the record, I am not a Liberal; I'm happy to vote Labor federally, but the ACT branch is something elese again.)
    Fr Mick is, with all respect, being too modest in his ambitions. Quite a few Canberrans would be happy to go back to being run by the Commonwealth Department of Territories across the board.

  3. Normally my dictum is 'choose cockup before conspiracy', however in this case I think Fr MacAndrew has hit the nail on the head.
    The secular Australian Establishment is generally becoming more hostile to the Christian presence (except behind closed doors between consenting adults). This is hardly seen more clearly in the ACT Assembly and the stream of legislation it has spawned.
    Sadly, too, we see that the demise of nursing orders, and I expect the trickle of charitable benefice signal something about the lack of, perhaps not faith, but resolve on the part of the Christian people in Australia.
    These are hard economic times, but perhaps Catholics need to consider putting our money where our mouth is too.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. National Youth Ministry Convention planned for 2010

    The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference is inviting youth leaders from across the country to attend a Youth Ministry Convention in 2010, to draw them together for dialogue, network and exchange of ideas.

  2. Gay adoption case to go back to Tribunal

    The Catholic and Anglican Churches are praising a decision that overturned a finding favouring a gay couple's bid to become foster parents, with Sydney's Cardinal George Pell calling it a "helpful" step "in the right direction", said The Daily Telegraph.

  3. Deal humanely with asylum seekers : Vinnies

    The St Vincent de Paul Society is calling for fairness and compassion in dealing with asylum seekers and urged for a "humanitarian position" on the matter

  4. St Luke's eConference draws prison inmates, international participants

    Prisoners in Sydney's Long Bay and Silverwater prisons joined thousands of people from across Australia and as far away as Rome, Britain, the US and Ireland yesterday to learn more about the Gospel of Luke in an eConference.

  5. Cups King prays for win at racing Mass

    Emerging from the annual racing fraternity Mass at St Francis' Catholic church in Lonsdale St, Melbourne yesterday, Val Cummings and husband Cups King Bart Cummings said they were praying for another winner on race day.

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.